The Email Mistakes You Don’t Know You’re Making

Email is one of the highest-performing channels — until it’s not. You might be checking all the boxes (segmentation, personalization, automation), but your open and click rates still feel flat.

The problem? Most email marketing strategies over-rely on formulas and under-deliver on intent. Let’s unpack the quiet mistakes holding your emails back.

‍

1. You’re Writing for Everyone — and Reaching No One

Mass-blast emails written for broad segments often dilute the message. If it feels like it’s for everyone, it resonates with no one.

Instead of treating your list as a monolith, look for moments of intent. Someone who just downloaded a guide may need a nudge, while a long-time subscriber may require reactivation. Behavior-driven targeting helps create context — and context is what makes content land.

Subject lines should also reflect the recipient’s mindset. For example, “Still thinking about [X]?” feels timely and specific, while “Check out our newsletter” lands flat.

A good email feels like it’s arriving right when someone needs it.

‍

2. Your Emails Look Great — but Don’t Read Well

Over-designed emails with heavy visuals can actually suppress engagement. People skim emails the way they scroll social feeds — fast and distracted.

A clean layout with short, punchy sentences gives your message breathing room. If it looks like a personal note, people are more likely to treat it that way.

Plain-text emails often outperform because they feel direct, unfiltered, and more trustworthy. When in doubt, simplify.

Plain-text style emails often outperform because they feel real.

‍

3. You’re Not Treating the Preview Text Like a Headline

Preview text is the secret weapon of high-performing email campaigns. It appears right next to your subject line — and offers a second chance to win the open.

When left blank or allowed to default to boilerplate text, it signals low effort. Instead, use it to amplify the hook: tease what’s inside, highlight urgency, or build contrast with the subject line.

Fix it with:

• A curiosity-driven lead-in to the subject line
• Questions or open loops
• Friendly tone that mirrors a real conversation

‍

4. Your Call-to-Action Is Either Missing or Misaligned

A strong CTA is more than a button — it’s a directional cue that guides the reader’s next step. Too many emails bury the ask or present multiple competing actions.

Instead, focus the message around one clear goal. Whether it's booking a call, reading a case study, or claiming an offer, make it frictionless.

Fix it with:

• One clear CTA per email
• Placement that fits the natural reading flow
• Button text that explains the benefit, not just the action

‍

5. You’re Ignoring Timing and Cadence

Even the best email can flop if it arrives at the wrong time — or too often. Many marketers underestimate how much timing influences engagement.

Sending too frequently leads to fatigue, while long gaps cause disengagement. Worse, sending without analyzing recipient behavior means you’re guessing when they’re most likely to act.

How to fix it:

• Test different send times by segment
• Use time zone targeting to reach people during active hours
• Monitor unsubscribe trends for signs of over-sending

Great timing makes good content feel even more relevant — and welcomed.

‍

Final Thought

Your audience doesn’t hate email — they just ignore the irrelevant, impersonal, or forgettable ones.

When you shift focus from what the brand wants to what the reader needs, performance shifts too. Clarity beats clever. Relevance beats routine. And empathy drives results.